• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Safety Risk .net

Humanising Safety and Embracing Real Risk

  • Home
    • About
      • Privacy Policy
      • Contact
  • FREE
    • FREE SAFETY eBOOKS
    • Free Hotel and Resort Risk Management Checklist
    • FREE DOWNLOADS
    • TOP 50
    • FREE RISK ASSESSMENT FORMS
    • Find a Safety Consultant
    • Free Safety Program Documents
    • Psychology Of Safety
    • Safety Ideas That Work
    • HEALTH and SAFETY MANUALS
    • FREE SAFE WORK METHOD STATEMENT RESOURCES
    • Whats New In Safety
    • FUN SAFETY STUFF
    • Health and Safety Training
    • SAFETY COURSES
    • Safety Training Needs Analysis and Matrix
    • Top 20 Safety Books
    • This Toaster Is Hot
    • Free Covid-19 Toolbox Talks
    • Download Page – Please Be Patient With Larger Files…….
    • SAFETY IMAGES, Photos, Unsafe Pictures and Funny Fails
    • How to Calculate TRIFR, LTIFR and Other Health and Safety Indicators
    • Download Safety Moments from Human Resources Secretariat
  • PSYCH. OF SAFETY & RISK
    • What is Psychological Safety at Work?
    • Safety Psychology Terminology
    • Some Basics on Social Psychology & Risk
    • Understanding The Social Psychology of Risk – Prof Karl E. Weick
    • The Psychology of Leadership in Risk
    • Conducting a Psychology and Culture Safety Walk
    • The Psychology of Conversion – 20 Tips to get Started
    • Understanding The Social Psychology of Risk And Safety
    • Psychology and safety
    • The Psychology of Safety
    • Hot Toaster
    • TALKING RISK VIDEOS
    • WHAT IS SAFETY
    • THE HOT TOASTER
    • THE ZERO HARM DEBATE
    • SEMIOTICS
    • LEADERSHIP
  • Robert Long
    • ALL POSTS
    • Learning Styles Matter
    • There is no HIERARCHY of Controls
    • Scaffolding, Readiness and ZPD in Learning
    • What Can Safety Learn From Playschool?
    • Presentation Tips for Safety People
    • Dialogue Do’s and Don’ts
    • It’s Only a Symbol
    • Ten Cautions About Safety Checklists
    • Zero is Unethical
    • First Report on Zero Survey
    • There is No Objectivity, Deal With it!
  • Slogans
    • Researchers Reveal the Top 10 Most Effective Safety Slogans Of All Time
    • When Slogans Don’t Work
    • CLASSIC, FAMOUS and INFAMOUS SAFETY QUOTES
    • BEST WORKPLACE HEALTH and SAFETY SLOGANS 2022
    • CATCHY and FUNNY SAFETY SLOGANS FOR THE WORKPLACE
    • COVID-19 (Coronavirus, Omicron) Health and Safety Slogans and Quotes for the Workplace
    • Safety Acronyms
    • You know Where You Can Stick Your Safety Slogans
    • Sayings, Slogans, Aphorisms and the Discourse of Simple
    • Spanish Safety Slogans – Consignas de seguridad
    • Safety Slogans List
    • Road Safety Slogans 2022
    • How to write your own safety slogans
    • Why Are Safety Slogans Important
    • Safety Slogans Don’t Save Lives
    • 40 Free Safety Slogans For the Workplace
    • Safety Slogans for Work
  • Safety Culture
    • Safety Culture Silences
  • Psychological Safety
You are here: Home / Robert Long / A Comparison of Safety Paradigms

A Comparison of Safety Paradigms

September 30, 2013 by Dr Rob Long 4 Comments

Another VERY interesting article by Dr Robert Long, one of the most succinct and useful comparisons of the various safety paradigms that I have come across. Again, no apologies to the Zero Harm fans! If you liked this article then you should read the whole series: CLICK HERE. I highly recommend you check out Rob’s new book “RISK MAKES SENSE”

A Comparison of Safety Paradigms?

A paradigm is a distinct set of concept and thinking that result in distinct practices. In recent times it has occurred to coroners at inquests, auditors and government that poor safety culture has a central role in normalising unsafe practice. Inspectors and auditors are now ever mindful that despite physical, technological, engineering, administrative and legislative measures to control safety, people are still being injured at work. We now know that these five controls in themselves are not the complete story about safety. Unfortunately when regulators and regulating agencies talk about safety culture and change, they tend to have little expertise or idea in how to influence it. So, they continue to swamp the safety world with more systems despite the fact that everyone around yells at them: ‘we are flooded by systems’. This is because a paradigm constrains one’s ability to understand the world outside of itself. So when humans make mistakes because they are overwhelmed by complexity, what do we do? Create more systems.

We all want the same thing but how do we get there?

Everyone interested in safety and wants the same outcomes, they don’t want anyone to be hurt. Injuries, whether physical or psychological, rarely bring pain to the just an individual. Injuries always have a domino effect and so the pain flows on to family, friends, business, organisations, employment arrangements, insurance, medical and therapeutic services. Any business that has regard for their employees and their families wants the best for them. It is also in their best business interests that they see employees at work the next day. Business interruption and disruption is costly and also has a domino effect disrupting morale, motivation and confidence. Disconnectedness in safety vision and language can also generate negativity, scepticism, double-speak and unethical practice. These are the values that are sometimes evident in sub-cultures in organisational safety cultures that invisibly work against safety, development and learning.

What works?

There is much evidence to show that negativity, punishment and rigidity have little longitudinal effect in changing behaviour. The prison system is a testimony to the fact that punishment doesn’t work. Whilst demand for more correctional facilities continues to increase the recidivism rate remains extremely high. From the time of the convicts we don’t seem to have learned much from history about punishment. Whilst simplistic approaches to zero tolerance are espoused by various factions in the media, most educationalists know that the result of such policies entrenches resentment and nothing much is learned or owned by the victims of the policy. Longitudinally, zero tolerance drives reporting underground, develops a sub-culture of cynicism and disregards all that is known about how people really learn and change? Unless people are motivated positively to change and own the values associated with that change then the desired behaviour will not be realised or worse still is only realised whilst the agents of control are around.

The following table may prove instructive.

Orthodox Safety Behaviour Based Safety Zero Tolerance Safety Psychosocial Safety
Key Words SystemsRules

Compliance

Legislation

Regulation

Codes of Practice

BehaviourHuman Error

Actions

 

ComplianceRegulations

Legislation

Policing Rules

Consequence

MotivationLearning

Development

Ownership

Encouragement

Values

Beliefs

UnderpinningFoundations Taylorism(Heinrich) Behaviourism(Skinner) Broken Window Theory(Wilson and Kelling) Self Actualisation(Maslow)
View of People People are parts of scientific management People are like machines and are the sum of inputs and outputs People make choices and think according to rules and rule breaking People are complex and follow what they value
Strategy for Change Engineering, technology, invention and design Negative and positive reinforcementBehaviour changes values PunishmentAuthority and control change culture MotivationCulture changes as people develop ownership of values
Focus Question How can the environment be changed? How can behaviour be changed? How can breaches be enforced? How do people learn?
View of Culture Culture is systems Culture is behaviours Culture is rules Culture is values
View of Organisations Management move parts like a chess game MechanisticReality is the sum of what I can observe A traditional hierarchy with strong lines of command and control Organisations are organic and a complexity of interrelated systems of people, groups and values
Sub-cultures Lemmings and LionsTechnology saves

Uniformity through engineered shaping

Depersonalised machine like processesTargeting indifference

Going through the motions

Uniformity through process

Hidden resentmentChampions and Misfits

Uniformity through compliance

EngagementHumanising

Understanding diversity

Harmony through

understanding

Training Technical focus, expertise in regulation Doing and practicing Learning the rules and reinforcing the consequences Engagement and influencing thinking and values
Essential Concepts Humans fit the machine Changing observable acts Policing the rules SensemakingMindfulness, influencing the unconscious

  • Bio
  • Latest Posts
  • More about Rob
Dr Rob Long

Dr Rob Long

Expert in Social Psychology, Principal & Trainer at Human Dymensions
Dr Rob Long

Latest posts by Dr Rob Long (see all)

  • Skilled Conversations in Risk and Safety - August 19, 2022
  • Traditional Safety - August 18, 2022
  • Understanding Safety Incentive Schemes, A Question of Balance - August 18, 2022
  • How to be a Safety Extremist - August 15, 2022
  • No Safety in Numbers - August 13, 2022
Dr Rob Long
PhD., MEd., MOH., BEd., BTh., Dip T., Dip Min., Cert IV TAA, MRMIA Rob is the founder of Human Dymensions and has extensive experience, qualifications and expertise across a range of sectors including government, education, corporate, industry and community sectors over 30 years. Rob has worked at all levels of the education and training sector including serving on various post graduate executive, post graduate supervision, post graduate course design and implementation programs.

Please share our posts

  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: Robert Long, Zero Harm Tagged With: safety culture, Safety Engagement, safety paradigm, Safety Paradigms, safety professional, safety programs, Safety Systems

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Search and Discover More on this Site

Never miss a post - Subscribe via Email

Enter your email address and join other discerning risk and safety people who receive notifications of new posts by email

Join 7,463 other subscribers

VIRAL POST!!! HOW TO QUIT THE SAFETY INDUSTRY

NEW! Free Download

Please take our 2 minute zero survey

Recent Comments

  • Jamespocket Door on Understanding The Social Psychology of Risk And Safety
  • Jamespocket Door on Understanding The Social Psychology of Risk And Safety
  • Rob Long on How to be a Safety Extremist
  • Mardi Meadors on How to be a Safety Extremist
  • Admin on How to Calculate TRIFR, LTIFR and Other Health and Safety Indicators
  • Rob Long on How to be a Safety Extremist
  • Jayesh Patel on How to Calculate TRIFR, LTIFR and Other Health and Safety Indicators
  • Rob Long on How to be a Safety Extremist
  • Admin on How to be a Safety Extremist
  • Rob Long on How to be a Safety Extremist
  • Rob Long on How to be a Safety Extremist
  • Andrew Floyd on How to be a Safety Extremist
  • grumpy on How to be a Safety Extremist
  • Rob Long on How to be a Safety Extremist
  • Ray on How to be a Safety Extremist
  • Rob Long on How to Leave the Safety Industry
  • Wynand on How to Leave the Safety Industry
  • Brian Edwin Darlington on How to Leave the Safety Industry
  • Brian Edwin Darlington on Culture Silences in Safety – What Culture Isn’t
  • Rob Long on How to Leave the Safety Industry

FREE eBOOK DOWNLOADS

Footer

Top Posts & Pages. Sad that most are so dumb but this is what safety luves

  • BEST WORKPLACE HEALTH and SAFETY SLOGANS 2022
  • Free Safety Moments and Toolbox Talk Examples, Tips and Resources
  • CATCHY and FUNNY SAFETY SLOGANS FOR THE WORKPLACE
  • Road Safety Slogans 2022
  • Skilled Conversations in Risk and Safety
  • 15 Safety Precautions When Working With Electricity
  • What Is Safety?
  • FREE RISK ASSESSMENT FORMS, CHECKISTS, REGISTERS, TEMPLATES and APPS
  • Download Safety Moments from Human Resources Secretariat
  • IDEAS FOR SAFETY TOOL BOX TALKS, HARD HAT CHATS and SAFETY MOMENTS

Recent Posts

  • Skilled Conversations in Risk and Safety
  • Traditional Safety
  • Understanding Safety Incentive Schemes, A Question of Balance
  • The Different Levels of Wrongness!
  • How to be a Safety Extremist
  • No Safety in Numbers
  • The Safety Spoilsport
  • The Safety Worldview and the Worldview of Safety, Testing Due Diligence
  • The Enemy of Safety – Humans
  • The Sacred Bra Tree
  • Understanding Psychological Terminology
  • Beware False Profits and Messiahs in Safety
  • Risk Boldly
  • Poetics of the Self
  • Culture Silences in Safety – What Culture Isn’t
  • There is No Objectivity, Deal With it!
  • When Only More Guilt Will Do
  • How to Leave the Safety Industry
  • Keep Counting Every Time You Don’t Achieve Your Goal, That’s Professional
  • Safety and Non-Neuroscience
  • Paperwork and Usability in Tackling Risk
  • Safety as a Masculinist Activity
  • You Don’t Want a Compliance Culture
  • The Soul of Mental Health
  • Identity and Safety
  • Psychosocial Controls and Measures for Who?
  • Linguistics and Safety
  • Not a Profession’s Bootlace
  • Cultural Silences in Safety – Power and Politics
  • History and Safety
  • What is Psychosocial Safety
  • It’s the –ism That Matters
  • A Guide to Psychosocial Safety Skills
  • Doing Away With Health and Safety–Language and People
  • The New Enemy of Safety – The Unconscious
  • Tape Down Those Leads
  • More Safety Code to Disguise Behaviourism
  • Why Safety is Attracted to Behaviourism
  • Safety Culture–Hudson’s Model
  • Understanding Safety as an Archetype
  • The Purpose of Safety
  • Learning Styles Matter
  • Due Diligence and Holistic Ergonomics Workshops
  • Having FUN in Safety FUNdamentalism
  • 80% of Safety Practitioners Are Idiots
  • Risk Homeostasis Theory–Why Safety Initiatives Go Wrong
  • Culture Silences in Safety – Semiotics
  • Flooding is Dangerous, and I don’t Mean the Water….
  • Cultural Silences in Safety – Aesthetics
  • Impacts of Cognitive Dissonance in the Workplace

FEATURED POSTS

All Risk is Subjective

Work-Life and Risk, Feminine Perspectives

7 Incredible Ways To Diagnose Risk More Effectively

Sticks and Stones and the Nonsense of Zero Harm

Cultivating Resilience

Managing the Unexpected

Not Much Like Safety…

Sexual Stereotyping Can Be Deadly

Safety is the Wrong Anchor

Actions in ‘Bad Faith’

Social Psychology of Risk Doability

‘Man Up’ Safety

Visual Learning and Envisioning Risk

A Letter To The Editor

Holistic Well Being in Risk Differently

How Semiotics Affects The Return To Work Process

WHS Legislation is NOT about Safety it’s about Culture

A Parallel Universe in Safety

No Gurus, No Stars, No Heroes Needed in Safety

Envisioning and Creativity in Safety

Evidence, Proof and Paperwork in Safety

Free Poster–Risk

Safety Investigation – Whodunit?

Rhetoric and Reality in Safety

Test Your Reaction Times

The Illusion Of Opposites

Safety-1, Safety-2, Safety-3

Paperwork and Usability in Tackling Risk

Gesture in Risk Matters

Pascal’s Wager and Sacred Safety

How does collective mindfulness apply to workers compensation?

Understanding The Social Psychology of Risk And Safety

When the Target Drives the Method

Psychometric Testing and Safety

Risk You Can Eat

The Moment of Decision in Safety

The Human Race…

Risk Leadership

Safety Myopia

Keep Discovering

More Posts from this Category

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address and join other discerning risk and safety people who receive notifications of new posts by email

Join 7,463 other subscribers

How we pay for the high cost of running of this site – try it for free on your site

What is Psychological Safety at Work?