Performance, Conformance and Informance in Safety
Eberle states in Dangerous Words that: ‘Much religious language ‘performs’ rather than ‘informs’.
So much of what is ‘performed’ in the name of safety is more about theatre than reality. After all the completion of paperwork done as ‘tick and flick’ one is left with nothing more than a ritual performance.
The language of ‘performance’ is found everywhere in safety, usually attributed to the measurement of actions but, what is ignored is the way in which performance is understood as an act.
Elam (The Semiotics of Theatre and Drama ) captures well this idea of acts of performance. In such an understanding, the act of something as ritual becomes the imagined reality simply by its repetition and ‘show’. This is always accompanied by religious language of salvation and belief as part of the religious ‘performance’. When rituals are performed effectiveness is attributed to the ritual even though there is none. Chants and mantras manifest belief regardless of whether such belief is well founded. For example, you can chant ‘safety is a choice you make’, ‘zero harm’ or ‘all accidents are preventable’ but if things ever get to court such delusional chants will be busted as attributions.
If you visit the global zero movement website you can find endless religious language about belief and effectiveness, even though there is none. You can read, watch and hear as much zero propaganda as you want but, there is no evidence that any of this chanting ‘works’. After all the performance, chanting and mantra repetition, nothing is different. The 7 golden rules are just traditional safety (https://visionzero.global/guides ). All the videos (https://visionzero.global/videos ) are just about the repetition of belief language, there is nothing more than theatre and performance. All the ‘news’ (https://visionzero.global/news ) is about evangelical performance to convert people to zero. All the language of vision (https://visionzero.global/why-vision-zero ) is not about vision but theatre, putting health and safety on ‘show’. It’s all about the ‘campaign’ performance, about repeating the nonsense mantra ‘the world of work without accidents and diseases is possible’ (https://visionzero.global/powerpoints ). Yes, and I believe in Unicorns!
When you read all the promotion and statements of ‘philosophy’ there is no statement of philosophy! When you see reasons to believe in zero it’s all about metrics and numerics. When you read about what to do, it’s just more marketing language of performance and theatre.
And all this language of belief triggers emotional anchoring much more than non-religious language.
All this language of belief attributes some supernatural force to such belief. Look at the video Spirit of Zero and you will see what I mean: https://safetyrisk.net/the-spirit-of-zero/
This emphasis on belief takes zero from the realms of everyday reality and presents it as a religious performance. Come join our theatrical performance and this demonstrates you believe! This repetition of ‘I believe in zero’ takes one out of space and time reality to a new level so that mortality and fallibility can be denied (https://safetyrisk.net/the-mortal-affliction-zero-and-safety/ ). All this belief places Zero as a ‘higher power’. One that can restore limbs and give everlasting life.
Watch the video below!
So, the best way to ensure conformance to the cult of zero (https://safetyrisk.net/the-cult-ure-of-zero/ ) is through the repetitions of belief, the performance of conformance and this becomes one’s informance.
Dr Rob Long
Latest posts by Dr Rob Long (see all)
- Not Just Another ‘Hazard’ - February 3, 2023
- How to Be Oriented Towards Psychosocial and Mental Health in Safety - February 2, 2023
- Free Download – Real Risk – New Book by Dr Robert Long - February 2, 2023
- ISO 45003 and What it Cannot Do - February 1, 2023
- Harming People in the Name of Good - January 31, 2023
Rob Long says
Of course the silence of the AIHS BoK on zero is also telling, In all of its chapters and spruiking its body of non-knowledge there is no mention of zero, the global mantra for the industry. The denial and deceitfulness is extraordinary.
Moreso, in the chapter on non-ethics there is no mention of zero either, the global language for brutalism.
The psychosis of the AIHS about zero is more than hilarious. This article says it all: https://safetyrisk.net/sia-has-a-bet-each-way-on-zero/
Admin says
Global Vision Zero conference is coming to Sydney in 2023 – should be quite a performance! I still cannot believe how ridiculous that video is
Rob Long says
Can you just imagine the BS that will flow in 2023 and of course all associations addicted to the snake oil and driveling to the belief juice and the Spirit of zero whilst at the and time denying they believe in zero, when they always have. They won’t be able to hide it in 2023 as they have in the past, should help them lose a huge proportion of membership.
Admin says
Oh yes there will be some spin and squirming. Saw a recent post from Workcover NSW about how excited they were for the conference. I asked where they stood on Vision Zero and no response. Must be hard for the peak bodies not to support the agenda of those with the sponsorship chequebook.
Rob Long says
Yes, the associations try to play this game of being ‘agnostic’ about zero which of course is not true. In doing so they hope that such spin will help them maintain the cult of zero whilst at the same time accepting money from the zero lovers. The way this all works is rather insidious and relies on people not questioning affiliations and ideology of the global safety industry. When you can authorize such a video as ‘Spirit of Zero’ you really have drunk the cool aid.
There is no neutrality with this stuff, you either ignore the ideology and thereby endorse it or you recognize the trajectory of the ideology and what it fosters.
Interestingly, no workers and most safety people don’t believe any of it and so the associations further alienate these groups.
Just watch the mental gymnastics in 2023 in Sydney. I’m hoping to have my next book on zero out before then.
Admin says
Hah! I forgot about that agnostic response from AIHS – hilarious
Admin says
https://safetyrisk.net/sia-has-a-bet-each-way-on-zero/