Someone sent me a thing the other day labelled as ‘brilliance’ and it was yet just another safety gimmick that yet again served as a distraction from discussing the essentials in safety – listening, helping, caring and learning.
This is what safety does so well. It creates gimmicks and labels them as ‘thought leading’ or thought bubbles and labels them ‘brilliant’ only to sell some ‘trinket to the natives’ as a strategy of avoidance. This idea was about a pre-job meeting and ‘gathering information’.
Whenever we see a safety gimmick the key is to analyse the language and the source of power. Listen for what is missing, observe what language is used and not used. Most often the gimmick involves a symbolic myth wither in text, symbol or gesture.
Gimmicks by definition are designed to attract attention and by design draw attention away from something else. It is one of the great devices of Propaganda. Create a distraction and name it as what it is not and sell the ‘kool aid’ as a health drink. This is the code of Safety.
Gimmicks have no value and promise much but include nothing of substance. Often a slogan is attached to the gimmick but the methodology and method is hidden. Indeed, when a set of slogans is presented as a method, there is none. Slogans are a gimmick of distraction to avoid attention to the basics.
For the undiscerning (https://www.humandymensions.com/product/real-risk/) who lack skills in critical thinking (https://safetyrisk.net/culture-silences-in-safety-critical-thinking/) the promise of substance in slogans is an illusion. The when the memory of the gimmick dwindles one wonders why it didn’t work, and wait for the next gimmick from some proclaimed guru to sell another gimmick. Or, one returns to traditional safety because one discovers that the gimmick has no substance. This is also known as Yo-Yo safety (https://safetyrisk.net/the-yo-yo-delusion-and-conversations-about-risk/).
It’s like the burden of the myth of the ‘safety moment’ or ‘safety share’. Once the myth of the gimmick fades the poor old worker is left with yet another burden of obligation that doesn’t help them tackle risk. In Building and Construction in Australia such a useless obligation is the White Card.
The trouble is once a myth is empowered by symbolism it is nearly impossible to jettison.
This is how Safety creates endless bureaucracy and process that add nothing to ‘helping’ workers tackle risk. Industrial manslaughter is the same (https://safetyrisk.net/why-i-do-not-support-industrial-manslaughter/).
This is how the industry ends up with so much useless paperwork that adds nothing of value to risk assessment and importantly has no legal value (https://vimeo.com/162034157).
This is how the industry ends up with useless gimmicks like Bow-Tie, Matrices, Swiss-Cheese etc that create obligation and distraction so that we once again lose sight of the fundamentals – listening, care, helping and learning. And we know this is real, because there still remains no focus on these basics in any safety curriculum or incident investigation across the globe.
3. PAPERWORK from Human Dymensions on Vimeo.
Dr Rob Long
Latest posts by Dr Rob Long (see all)
- Critical Thinking Needed More Than Ever in Safety - January 21, 2025
- Selling Safety and the Safety of Selling Safety Culture - January 19, 2025
- Hearing Voices - January 18, 2025
- You Can’t ‘Bust’ Myths - January 18, 2025
- There is No Such Thing as an HRO - January 18, 2025
Steve Thompson says
I’m in the US and have my two OSHA 10 Cards (Construction and General Industry). Apparently I’m skilled in recognizing safety hazards and avoiding injury :-). Great article Dr. Long!
grumpy says
White Card = gimmick? Surely not! #sarc.
I was asked to get a White Card while working at a non-construction business in NSW so I could be involved in a major capital project on site.
You can’t obtain a NSW White Card online, you must do a face to face course.
You could (at the time) get a Qld White Card online.
The NSW company paid for my online Qld White Card course.
My Qld White Card is accepted nationally, including in NSW.
I cannot recall a single thing about my White Card training, but I am safe to work on any construction site in Australia for the rest of my life.
Admin says
And fortunes are being made scamming the white card system. My kids used to do all my online inductions for me and earned some good pocket money
Rob Long says
My son works in building and construction and had to get a white card, as did I.
This is completely ignored because companies know it is useless so, they all re-induct people to the basics And this occurs again and again for each job.
It’s a joke.