Social Psychology of Risk

No Accident? No Problem! Barry and Sadie Investigate Anyway

By Barry Spud and Sadie Tater — professional colleagues in compliance. An original satire 

Barry:

Zero Harm nearly killed the noble art of accident investigation.

Not because accidents stopped. Reporting stopped.

We made the monthly barbecue dependent on an injury-free record. Within weeks, workers discovered that back pain was temporary but being blamed for cancelling sausages could last forever.

Our statistics were magnificent.

My investigation business was collapsing.

The problems with zero targets and under-reporting are discussed on SafetyRisk. However, nobody mentions the distress caused to consultants with unused root-cause templates.

Then Professor Toddler Conk-Out introduced us to pre-accident investigation.

Finally. An investigation business unconstrained by the availability of accidents.

Sadie:

Previously, we needed an event, evidence and some indication that something had happened.

Now we could walk into a perfectly functioning workplace and announce:

“We’re here about the accident.”

“What accident?”

“The one you haven’t had yet.”

Nobody can contradict an event that hasn’t happened. They can only demonstrate insufficient appreciation of its potential.

Barry:

To be fair, the sensible idea underneath is to learn about everyday work before people get hurt.

Ask workers about difficulties. Understand conditions. Examine how work succeeds despite inadequate arrangements.

Perfectly reasonable.

Unfortunately, “talking with people about their work” doesn’t have quite the same commercial presence as PRE-ACCIDENT INVESTIGATION™.

One sounds like something a competent supervisor might already do.

The other requires a facilitator, a workshop and a budget.

Sadie:

Rob Long asks Are You Living in a Pre-Accident? and challenges the idea of investigating something that hasn’t happened.

We consider that our principal advantage.

An actual accident creates awkward constraints. There are facts, witnesses and a sequence of events.

A hypothetical accident offers greater creative freedom.

Barry can draw the causal diagram first and then find an ordinary activity to place inside it.

Barry:

Our first investigation concerned a worker successfully moving equipment through a doorway.

“What makes this difficult?” I asked.

“The approved trolley doesn’t fit,” he said. “We use this smaller one.”

There it was.

An adaptation.

Previously, I might have mistaken this for practical knowledge. Through our new investigative lens, I could recognise it as a precursor.

A precursor to what?

We hadn’t decided.

But it was definitely preceding something.

Sadie:

That is the beauty of calling everyday work a pre-accident.

Every adjustment becomes suspicious.

Every successful task becomes an accident that hasn’t matured.

Every worker becomes a potential witness to their own future failure.

Barry calls it proactive learning.

I call it getting our statement before they have an alibi.

Barry:

We invited everyone to a learning team.

Participation was open, provided it stayed within our predetermined scope.

Workers wanted to discuss staffing, unreliable equipment and purchasing decisions.

We wanted to discuss how workers responded to staffing, unreliable equipment and purchasing decisions.

A subtle distinction.

The first might require management to change something.

The second could be addressed with a behavioural commitment.

Rob Long’s criticism of new rhetoric with the same old dynamics is inconveniently relevant here.

We have renamed the meeting.

We have not surrendered the chair.

Sadie:

Our questions were beautifully open.

“What difficulties do you encounter?”

“How do you manage them?”

“Would you agree that the solution is the procedure Barry has already written?”

We recorded every contribution.

Then we translated the workers’ untidy stories into categories our software understood.

Uncertainty became a score.

Disagreement became a communication issue.

A purchasing failure became an opportunity for operator awareness.

By the time we finished, everyone’s voice had been heard and nobody could recognise what they had said.

Barry:

Then came the controls.

Additional approvals. More forms. Restricted equipment. Mandatory briefings.

We removed the smaller trolley because it wasn’t in the procedure.

The approved trolley still didn’t fit.

Deliveries backed up. Workers stayed late. Fatigue increased. People handled loads they previously moved on wheels.

Eventually, there was a collision and a handling injury.

Our intervention had helped create the conditions for actual accidents.

Sadie was delighted with the predictive accuracy.

“We knew this was a pre-accident!”

Sadie:

A worker suggested our controls had made things worse.

We explained that this was precisely why further investigation was necessary.

Our method is remarkably resilient.

If nothing happens, our intervention prevented it.

If something happens, our original concern was justified.

If the intervention contributes to what happens, implementation requires improvement.

There is no disappointing result. Only another engagement.

Barry:

The real danger in questioning and investigation is that someone might expect us to listen without steering, reconsider our assumptions or share control of the conclusions.

We prefer workers to share their expertise while we retain ownership of what it means.

Otherwise, learning could become unpredictable.

Someone might even ask whether “pre-accident investigation” helps us understand everyday work—or merely teaches us to see everyday work as evidence for an accident we have imagined.

We have referred that question to a subcommittee.

Sadie:

Business is thriving again.

We now investigate work before it happens, while it happens and after our recommendations interfere with it.

Our new company slogan is:

“NO ACCIDENT REQUIRED. CONCLUSIONS AVAILABLE NOW.”

Barry:

And if you’re still operating successfully?

Don’t worry.

We haven’t finished helping.

Barry Spud

Barry Spud

Safety Crusader, BBS Fanatic, Zero Harm Zealot, Compliance Controller and Global Pandemic Expert at Everything Safety
Barry Spud

2 Comments

  1. Thanks Barry and Sadie

    The spin of pre-accident investigation is yet again just another con. So, everything we do now becomes a pre-accident. It’s the same spin with the propaganda of learning from ‘normal’ work and the nonsense of learning when nothing goes wrong. No wonder Safety loves this stuff.

    Just imagine if we ran education institutions on the premise that we learned when nothing went wrong? There would be no need for exams, tests or essays, don’t let those pesky mistakes get in the way of learning. I can just see it now. I walk up to my professor after getting 45% on an exam and tell her to look at all I did right. Wonderful.

    Of course, the con is perfect for an industry that lacks the critical capability to question the con. Indeed, keep repeating the word ‘principle’ for a slogan and make it so.

    1. Barry: Only 45%? You’re focusing on failure. I see 45 successful learning outcomes and 65 opportunities for a follow-up invoice, 110% safety. We no longer mark answers wrong—we investigate the context in which they became locally correct.

      Sadie: And that exam was clearly a pre-graduation incident. We’ve introduced six controls, suspended the professor’s marking privileges and formed a learning team to establish why her assessment differed from our preferred result.

      Barry: Naturally, learning from everyday work could include questioning ourselves. We’ve avoided that complication by declaring our conclusions ‘principles’. Workers provide the stories; we retain editing rights.

Do you have any thoughts? Please share them below